Case file Key facts Name: Scott Douglas Scarberry — known as “Scotty” (as reported by The Virginia Mountaineer) Age: 53 (as reported) Reported missing: July 2026 — after reportedly traveling to Buchanan County to explore abandoned mines (per The Virginia Mountaineer, July 24, 2026) A note on a circulated backstory: A “Huck Finn” Hurricane Helene … Read more
Key facts Name: Ann Gotlib (also listed as Anna; surname sometimes spelled Gotliv) Born: May 5, 1971, Kyiv, Ukrainian SSR, Soviet Union Age at disappearance: 12 Last seen: June 1, 1983, between 5:30 and 6:00 p.m. Location: Bashford Manor Mall, Louisville, Kentucky Height / build: 5’1″, 85 lbs, red/auburn hair, gray eyes; freckles, moles on … Read more
Key facts Name: Crystal Maria Rogers (née Ballard) Born: 1980, Bardstown, Kentucky Age at disappearance: 35 Last seen: July 3, 2015 Location: Bardstown, Kentucky (reported missing July 5, 2015) Height / build: Adult woman, mother of five Status: Still missing — body never found; three men convicted in 2025 in connection with her murder Investigating … Read more
Key facts Name: Erica Lee Fraysure Born: Circa 1980 Age at disappearance: 17 Last seen: October 21, 1997, between 9:00 and 10:00 p.m. Location: Video-N-Tan, Brooksville, Kentucky (Bracken County) Height / build: 17-year-old high school senior; strawberry birthmark on back of neck; last seen in purple sweater with white stripes, Levi’s jeans, white Keds, Winnie … Read more
Key facts Name: Heather Danielle Teague Born: April 25, 1972 Age at disappearance: 23 Last seen: August 26, 1995 Location: Newburgh Beach, Ohio River, Spottsville, Kentucky (Henderson/Webster County area) Height / build: 5’2″, 90–100 lbs, brown hair, green eyes; fallen arches, circular red birthmark on right buttock, scoliosis; last seen in a red plaid bathing … Read more
Key facts Name: Kelly Hollan Jr. (sometimes listed as Kelly Junior Hollan) Born: November 17, 1975 Age at disappearance: 6 Last seen: February 12, 1982 Location: Larks Lane, Pine Tree Hollow, Mousie, Knott County, Kentucky Height / build: 4’0″, 60 lbs, brown hair, blue eyes; cleft-palate scar on left side of face, speech impediment; last … Read more